"Of course it's hard to avoid comparing this with
Excite Truck, so I won't. I love Excite Truck, it's sooo much fun. Monster 4x4 isn't, it's boring even.
In Excite Truck the tracks are excellent, especially the many short-cuts, cool jump spots, racing through water, etc... In Monster 4x4 the tracks lack any imagination, they're short and bland. And they're all very similar too, even though they are supposedly located in exotic places like Athens, Barcelona, Moscow or San Francisco. Boooorrrinnnnggg.. Excite Truck's graphics are much better too.
At first glance the control system is similar, tilt the controller left and right to steer. But for some reason it works out great in Excite truck, but sucks in Monster 4x4. It feels like you are rotating the track beneath the car, as opposed to steering the car itself, very weird.
Ubisoft was smart to make sure this game was released before Excite Truck (it was a Wii launch game even), so they could shift some copies of it. But now Excite Truck is available, I really see no reason to buy Monster 4x4. I am glad I didn't, I borrowed it from a friend, just out of curiosity. He had already told me it wasn't very good and he was right.
Oh, BTW: Am I the only who is confused by menu interface in the World Circuit mode? After completing one race, on the results screen, if you choose Continue, the game asks "Are you sure you want to exit?" Eh no, I don't want to exit, I want to continue to the next race. So I choose No, which brings me back to the results screen. It turns out you have to choose Yes there. Weird, has this thing been play-tested at all?"